Educational quality and spin
Tuesday, May 22nd, 2007Yesterday, I was searching around for the results from the BBQ competition last weekend when I happened across this article about Tennessee students:
http://www.commercialappeal.com/mca/education/article/0,2673,MCA_22897_5547147,00.html
I was surprised and dismayed that my newly adopted state performed so poorly with regard to education (not that Oklahoma was particularly great). I thought “at least they are being honest about it.” A local paper actually covering such news is important.
Well, today, I’m searching around for other local news to find out where a rather scary “random” park shooting was, and I came across this article:
http://www.commercialappeal.com/mca/local/article/0,2845,MCA_25340_5549461,00.html
I thought that those articles were somewhat contradictory. It’s certainly possible for, say, the best school in the nation to be located in the worst district in the nation, it’s just not likely. So, I decided to find out a big more about the study mentioned in the article and I found the results posted here:
http://projects.washingtonpost.com/challengeindex/
It was good to see exactly what the study was supposed to show. Well, for one, it’s a “challenge” index and they state pretty clearly that they don’t include magnet schools, or charter schools with high (I’m paraphrasing here) composite ACT and/or SAT scores. I have plenty authority on the matter to tell you that magnet schools can certainly challenge their pupils. The mini Commercial Appeal article doesn’t mention this. They also include a nice disclaimer at the end, so maybe they expect more astute readers to catch them, but I’m sure the schools they mentioned will be touting this as “proof” of the quality education they provide, just as the article implies.
Well, I decided to take a look at the list a bit and see who is where, etc. Didn’t I just read that they leave out magnet and charter schools? Then why is the #1 school on the list named Talented and Gifted? Why is the #2 school named Science/Engineering Magnet? I start scrolling down the list and find a school I’m a bit more familiar with — Classen School of Advanced Studies. I know that’s a magnet/charter school. There are a bunch more just like that. Something seems a bit fishy to me. At the minimum, there needs to be some clarification, but I’m wondering if there was some funny business going on here to make somebody look good.

